| Name | Grad Year | School(s) | Sport(s) |
| RJ David | 2017 | Corbin University | Golf |
| Garret deFisser | 2017 | William & Mary | Golf |
| Jared Gross | 2017 | Dordt College | Football |
| Christian Kamerman | 2017 | Dordt College | Football |
| Jordan Larson | 2017 | Northern Arizona University | Track & Field |
| Megan Timmer | 2017 | Embry-Riddle | Basketball |
| Bethany Wolph | 2017 | Embry-Riddle | Basketball |
| Ethan DeWit | 2016 | University of Sioux Falls | Baseball |
| Hailey Heeringa | 2016 | Dordt College | Softball |
| Caleb Rutter | 2016 | Judson University | Basketball |
| Nat Andresen | 2015 | Western Nebraska CC | Baseball |
| Alyssa Braun | 2015 | Concordia University Irvine | Basketball |
| Skylar Cavanaugh | 2015 | Naval Academy | Track & Field |
| Eric Cochran | 2015 | Grand Canyon University | Track & Field |
| Gavin deFisser | 2015 | William & Mary | Golf |
| Ashley Harrison | 2015 | Concordia University Irvine | Track & Field |
| Trevor Lampson | 2015 | California Baptist | Golf |
| Christian Sanchez | 2015 | Northern Arizona University | Football |
| Keara Schromm | 2015 | California Lutheran | Soccer |
| Drew Steingenga | 2015 | Dordt College | Football |
| Mitchell Timmer | 2015 | Arizona Christian University | Basketball |
| Taylor Wiehl | 2014 | Chandler-Gilbert | Soccer |
| Owen Feenstra | 2014 | Wheaton | Wrestling |
| Will Carter | 2014 | Wisconsin-Superior | Basketball |
| Micah Izquierdo | 2014 | Phoenix College | Baseball |
| Christian Husband | 2014 | Arizona Christian/Crown College | Football |
| Brandon Haagsma | 2014 | Dordt College | Basketball |
| T.J. Widner | 2014 | San Diego / Arizona State University | Football |
| Jacob Rutter | 2014 | Southern Nazarene University | Football |
| Dayton Nussle | 2014 | Azusa Pacific University | Football |
| Nathan Basinger | 2014 | Grand Canyon University | Cross Country / Track & Field |
| Briana Jurries | 2013 | University of Michigan | Swimming |
| Jeff Paschke | 2013 | University of Southern California | Baseball |
| Bryan Timmer | 2013 | Dordt College | Basketball |
| Tana Kemmer | 2013 | Cornell College | Basketball / Softball |
| Carter Gladstone | 2013 | Arizona Christian / Northwest Missouri St | Baseball |
| Emily Shieh | 2013 | Grand Canyon University | Track & Field |
| Lindy Dyer | 2013 | Colorado Christian University | Volleyball |
| Kyla Gross | 2012 | Dordt College | Soccer |
| Katie File | 2012 | Anderson University | Volleyball |
| Nick Tallet | 2012 | Arizona Christian University | Baseball |
| Mikala Nelson | 2012 | Concordia University Irvine | Swimming |
| Skylar Kuzmich | 2012 | Mesa CC / South Mountain CC | Soccer |
| Sydney Tassielli | 2012 | Grand Canyon University | Track & Field |
| Chandler Fraley | 2012 | Liberty University | Track & Field |
| Ben Marshall | 2012 | Trinity International University | Football |
| Briena Barclay | 2011 | Vanguard University | Track & Field |
| Stacey Jones | 2011 | The Masters College | Volleyball |
| Jordan Morgan | 2011 | Northern Arizona / California | Football |
| Nathan Grimm | 2011 | Chandler Gilbert CC | Baseball |
| Tyler Owings | 2011 | Grand Canyon University | Track & Field |
| Ally Cheatham | 2011 | Baylor University | Acrobatics & Tumbling |
| Will Lane | 2011 | Western Arizona CC | Baseball |
| Ryan Cooper | 2011 | University of Arizona / Gateway CC / Grand Canyon Univ. | Baseball |
| Caleb Fraley | 2011 | Liberty University | Track & Field |
| Drew Bond | 2011 | Malone College | Football |
| Ashton Wolf | 2011 | West Point Academy (Army) | Handball / Softball |
| Quinn Robertson | 2010 | Azusa Pacific University | Swimming |
| Kyle James | 2010 | Bethal (MN) | Football |
| Kristen Johannsen | 2010 | Grand Canyon University | Volleyball |
| Chanel Brown | 2010 | Pepperdine / Arizona / Florida | Volleyball |
| Sara Vasquez | 2010 | Grand Canyon University | Cheer |
| Addison Bare | 2010 | Mesa CC | Track & Field |
| Kyle O’Brien | 2010 | Scottsdale CC | Football |
| Breanna Leslie | 2009 | Azusa Pacific University | Track & Field |
| Sean Newport | 2009 | Arizona State University | Cross Country / Track & Field |
| Hayley Temple | 2009 | Wichita State University | Softball |
| Stephen Sasso | 2009 | United States Merchant Marines | Football |
| Jordan Kerpan | 2009 | Trinity International University | Basketball |
| Shelby Richardson | 2009 | Drury | Softball |
| Daniel Fanelli | 2008 | Azusa Pacific University | Track & Field |
| Nate Van Weeldan | 2008 | Point Loma Nazarene University | Basketball |
| Greer Evans | 2008 | Arizona Christian University | Basketball |
| David Blasi | 2008 | Chandler Gilbert CC | Baseball |
| Sam Moore | 2008 | Arizona Christian / Grand Canyon / Oral Roberts | Baseball |
| Riley Barclay | 2008 | Arizona State University | Gymnastics |
| Zach Hyer | 2008 | Biola University | Golf |
| Paul Zackowski | 2008 | Case Western Reserve | Cross Country / Track & Field |
| Brendan Curletta | 2008 | Trinity International University | Baseball |
| Alaina Bergsma | 2008 | University of Oregon / Loyola Marymount | Volleyball |
| Joey Hormes | 2008 | Arizona State University | Basketball |
| Micah Kidd | 2008 | Azusa Pacific University | Track & Field |
| Kelsey Moore | 2008 | University of Texas El Paso | Volleyball |
| Bryant Avent | 2008 | Arizona Christian University | Basketball |
| Jon Harrison | 2007 | Mesa CC | Track & Field |
| Tanner Allen | 2007 | San Diego Christian | Baseball |
| Cameron Liston | 2007 | Arizona State / Northern Arizona | Cross Country / Track & Field |
| Alaina Stenson | 2007 | Arizona State University | Cheer |
| Kim Wigboldy | 2007 | Calvin College | Volleyball / Track & Field |
| Ali Gentry | 2007 | Phoenix College | Volleyball |
| Koby Temple | 2007 | Tabor College / Nebraska Omaha | Baseball |
| Shane Johannsen | 2007 | Northern Arizona University | Basketball |
| Corey Botma | 2007 | Point Loma Nazarene University | Cross Country / Track & Field |
| Isaac Remington | 2007 | University of Oregon | Football |
| Dane Rymer | 2006 | Claremont McKenna | Football |
| Frank Komadina | 2006 | Naval Academy | Swimming |
| Nathan Papadeaus | 2006 | UT Tyler / Biola | Baseball |
| Reggie Sheffield | 2006 | University of Arizona | Football |
| Phil Roffi | 2006 | Brown University | Football |
| Nick Van Weeldan | 2006 | Point Loma Nazarene University | Basketball |
| Ben Bergsma | 2006 | Claremont College | Basketball / Football |
| Sarah Visser | 2005 | Dordt College | Softball |
| Amanda Moore | 2005 | Arizona Christian University | Basketball |
| Dalen Linnerson | 2005 | South Mountain CC | Golf |
| Jessica Raak | 2004 | California Lutheran University | Cheer |
| Brian “Boomer” Roberts | 2004 | Vanguard University | Basketball |
| David Mehlhorn | 2004 | Arizona State University | Cross Country / Track & Field |
| Luke Jensen | 2004 | Arizona State / New Mexico | Baseball |
| Josh Lett | 2004 | Alabama Mobile | Baseball |
| Jennifer Ekstrand | 2004 | Masters College | Basketball |
| Julie-Anne Bailey | 2004 | Point Loma Nazarene University | Cross Country / Track & Field |
| Morganne Parsons | 2004 | Masters College | Volleyball |
| Paul Hardiman | 2003 | Azusa Pacific / Grambling State | Football |
| Alex Robertson | 2003 | Westmont / Trinity International | Basketball |
| Tim Kruge | 2003 | Point Loma Nazarene University | Basketball |
| Andrew Majesty | 2003 | Trinity International University | Football |
| Tyler Liston | 2003 | Trinity International University | Basketball |
| Matt Hill | 2003 | Trinity International University | Football |
| Eric Fraley | 2003 | Azusa Pacific / Trinity International | Football |
| Drew Rymer | 2002 | Claremont McKenna | Football |
| Kyle Smith | 2002 | Concordia University (CA) | Baseball |
| Missy Mehlhorn | 2002 | Pepperdine University | Volleyball |
| Kyle Brown | 2002 | Concordia University (CA) | Basketball |
| Quinton McCoy | 2002 | University of Michigan | Football |
| Adam Botma | 2002 | Point Loma Nazarene University | Cross Country / Track & Field |
| Jason Voss | 2002 | University of Utah | Football |
| Ruth Cain | 2001 | Phoenix College / Colorado Christian | Basketball |
| Mark Wilson | 2001 | Mesa CC | Baseball |
| Rilus Graham | 2001 | Texas Christian University | Swimming |
| Natalie Harris | 2000 | Arizona State University | Volleyball |
| Courtney Blocher | 2000 | Arizona State University | Volleyball |
| Kim Mehlhorn | 2000 | Arizona State University | Volleyball |
| Cheryl Anglin | 2000 | Arizona State University | Volleyball |
| Stacey Schugg | 2000 | New Mexico State University | Volleyball |
| Travis Schugg | 1998 | Alabama A&M | Football |
| Myra Anglin | 1997 | Point Loma Nazarene University | Volleyball |
| Misty Hawkinson | 1997 | Mesa CC | Volleyball / Track & Field |
| Stacey Saunders | 1997 | Mesa CC | Volleyball |
| Justin Anderson | 1997 | Point Loma Nazarene University | Baseball |
| Jen Wiechertjes | 1997 | Grand Canyon University | Volleyball |
| Carrie Bobb | 1996 | Southern Nazarene University | Volleyball |
| Michael Broek | 1996 | Arizona Christian University | Basketball |
| Justin Coyle | 1995 | San Diego Christian | Basketball |
| Ryan Yarbrough | 1994 | Azusa Pacific University | Basketball |
| Erica Cline | 1993 | Grand Canyon University / Phoenix College | Volleyball |
| Shawna Moskalik | 1993 | University of Iowa / Azusa Pacific | Volleyball |
| Jared Schreiber | 1993 | Arizona State University | Track & Field |
| Stacey Anglin | 1993 | Texas Wesleyan University | Volleyball |
| Armon Williams | 1992 | University of Arizona | Football / Track & Field |
| Taylor Perin | 1992 | Tennessee State University | Track & Field |
| Ty Hawkinson | 1991 | Mesa CC | Baseball |
| Scott Yarbrough | 1990 | Azusa Pacific University | Track & Field |
Know of a Valley Christian High School graduate who is competing athletically in college but not on our list?
Please contact us so we can add them!